Why I hate groups and why I’m a social outcast
Posted by enrico | Under Medical School, Personal Sunday Mar 26, 2006I said it: I can’t stand group activities. Those people with whom I’ve worked or are working in groups that happen to be reading this, I promise it’s not personal. I just prefer working by myself or with one or two other people of my choosing, but rarely more than that, and even then, selectively. My experience has almost always been that it was not the best use of my time either because of a different academic focus/seriousness or because socially it just didn’t gel.
It’s hard being in medical school. It’s hard being in medical school in another country, away from the support system of friends and family, much less your own country/language/culture/laws etc. etc. To add salt to the wound, it’s even harder to be here in your 30s going to school with classmates in their early-to-mid 20s; the difference in attitude, perspective, maturity, *cough*energy level*cough*–it can be hard sometimes. To add lime to the salt already in the wound, I’m fat and sometimes (unbeknownst to me) hard to get to know, because a) I’m fat, and/or b) I usually get misconstrued for being upset or something like that. Sometimes (b) is naively assumed because of (a), which is a silly oversimplification, apart from not even being true. Besides, aren’t all fat people supposed to be jolly?
I never did have a lot of patience in general, and I think with age, like your telomeres, it just gets shorter and shorter; there’s nothing you can really do about it, except fight the good fight against biology and “eat it” sometimes for the sake of social decorum. I feel frustrated because I always feel I have no time, and since time is so valuable, when my time is wasted (unfortunately, a nearly daily event at school) it’s doubly frustrating, because I’m thinking not only of what isn’t being done but what COULD be done if I weren’t there. I don’t want to be one of those harried med students too busy to do the simplest things in life because they are gunning for the top grades. I do strive for a balance, a harmony, and a sense of satisfaction for a job well done. However, I have this little voice inside me that irrationally says that if I say “Good job!” or something else that is approving, then the slacking will begin, the rationalization of not having to this or that will set in because, well, “I did a good job–surely I deserve a break,” or whatever.
I often want to study with others to help keep me on my toes, to help mix up my study patterns/time somewhat, just to add variety to an otherwise slogging task, if nothing else. This desire, contrasted with the easy frustration, high standards, social awkwardness, etc. provides a constant stressful dichotomy that’s not really resolved. It expresses itself like my intense mental drive to be as good as I can be clashing with my ubiquitously expressed slacker gene over which I seem to have no control, just variable management. I seem to constantly meet/know two kinds of people: 1) people with whom I get along great, could have fun and hang out with but have differing academic standards/levels/seriousness/etc. such that I think group/tandem studying would be ineffective or unbalanced, and 2) people with whom I think group study would be mutually beneficial, academically, but are too engrossed in their own lives to really have anything left to share, time-wise, for studying. These individuals are consumed with self-study or have something else in their lives taking all their out-of-class time–something understandable like their own family or something perhaps more incompatible with my current lifestyle, like excessive partying–that prevents me getting together with them in spite of a potentially productive session. (I am, of course, ignoring the people with whom I wouldn’t get along regardless and I’m definitely not counting the ever-hated, low-yield group “We’re all meeting at so-and-sos to eat/study, come along!”) In all situations, nobody has ever asked me to study with them in a 1:1/2:1 fashion, so it’s not like I’m turning down invitations and being picky. In fact, I have asked others to join in with them but then not get asked when the time came. I’m not hurt by this, but I do wonder–is it me? I refuse to believe that anyone in my class who halfway knows me actually thinks I wouldn’t be a positive academic contribution to a study session, so I’m left to wonder, am I just too “out there” for most people? Am I intimidating, too old, smelly, boring, overly-serious…I have no idea.
All I know is that here in Mexico, you already seem like you are going through too much on your own–life in general, as well as thrown to the wolves in terms of disorganized class materials–to not have the help from friends (as opposed to the “natural” cutthroat medschool environment) sharing and supporting each other, welcoming opportunities to spread the wealth and the work. I’m trying my best to work harder and smarter, but I’m also trying to not live in a box either. It seems simultaneously studying and socializing would fit that bill perfectly; it hasn’t happened yet.
I know exactly how you feel. I went to school in Grenada and had much the same culture shock for living in a different country, etc. (I grew up in NYC). I was in my mid-twenties, but was definitely a nerd. I had a few people I studied with, but I ran into much the same problem of differing academic levels, etc. I had a few friends and I knew there were a lot of people who did not like me. I mostly stuck to myself and those few friends and rarely found someone to study with. For me that worked, because I do better on my own for that sort of thing and since I graduated first in my class, it did work very well. Was it lonely? You betcha. Did I make it through? Yep. Do I give a rat’s posterior for most of those people now? Nope.
It’s doable. Our mantra was pass and move on. The only one you have to really measure yourself against is you. Do as well as you can, do well in your clinicals when you get to them, do well on your boards and you are set.
Great entry, Enrico. I hear you.
I had wonderful study partners, but there is always a balance to hit between studying alone and in groups. My maximum focus level is highest when I am by myself, but I am not always at that maximum. Studying with others helps keep me motivated. Either way, i am always feeling like I do not study enough. It is frustrating.
I am sorry that you feel excluded from your class. I can identify with this as well. The thing with me is that I don’t always want to be included, but then people stop asking and sometimes I feel left out. My advice would be to identify a list of people who you would like to get to know better and then actively organize something to do with them. For a social activity, dinner at home is nice with a group of new friends, or for a study activity, I like doing the Costanzo Cases and Problems book (Physiology). Wild, I know.
Hang in there. You’re doing great. I don’t know why I feel that I can tell this, but I do.
Julia: Thanks for your post…always good to hear from an IMG whose made it!
PB: Excellent advice, thanks…if I want something, I need to take responsibility for actively making it happen. As much as I was down a bit in my post, I really am just looking for ways to add variety to my studying by studying with others, mainly to keep myself motivated and focused, even if all we do is quiz each other. Thanks for your optimism.
Things will get a lot better when you do your clinical rotations. My circle of friends exploded from about 5 to about half the class just because we were all thrown together in different combinations on different rotations. It was actually the best part of the clinical years for me.
You are a perceptive writer and these community medicine posts highlight how different the real world, wherever we are, is from the tertiary care center where most of us do most of our medical learning, The Big Tent, I call it. I think because of this many of us opt for specialty work, some small corner we can keep in order. Your post make this point very well. Thanks
I well understand where you are coming from, it is easy to feel as a loaner in the high pace and stress environment of medical school studies. All medical students find a niche that works for them when studying, some enjoy groups while there are those such as myself that have always studied alone because I feel like I get more done at a faster pace but don’t get me wrong the few times I’ve studied with other classmates was also productive time spent. Just hang in there and remember you will BECOME A MEDICAL DOCTOR !!
I well understand what you are going through attending a foreign medical school, and YES, I too attended medical school at La Universidad Autonoma de Guadalajara in Mexico. I was in the entering class of 2003 and transferred to Ross University School of Medicine in 2005. I can tell you, please make the most of your education at Autonoma and of Mexico. Looking back, yes I’m glad I’m now back in the states; but I think fondly of my time at La Universidad Autonoma de Guadalajara Medical School even if it was for two years. They gave me a chance to pursue my dream of becoming A MEDICAL DOCTOR and for that I’ll always be sincerely thankful !!!
Hang in there and goodluck !! Doctor and future colleague !!
omg……i hear ya…wht can i say….thats the same happenin wid me ..lol